Through the first ten months of 2026, Michigan City posted the fastest median-price gain of any South Shore Line town compared here. That gain came a little more than a year after its new 11th Street Station opened. Munster got a brand-new rail line in March, and its median barely moved. If you're a Chicago buyer comparing towns along the tracks, that gap matters more than any one town's price. New train service and higher sale prices showed up roughly a year apart in Michigan City, and Munster is only seven months into that wait.
Below is how each station town looks once you put its typical train next to its year-to-date sales record.
Compare the typical train, since the express is the exception
When the Double Track NWI schedule launched in May 2024, the South Shore Line advertised limited-stop express times of 67 minutes from Michigan City, 57 from Dune Park and 51 from Portage/Ogden Dunes. The railroad's current timetable, effective April 2026, is a bit slower than those launch figures. Like any schedule, it can be revised.
Going by that April 2026 weekday timetable, the fastest scheduled westbound trip to Millennium Station is 68 minutes from Michigan City's 11th Street, 58 from Dune Park, 68 from Beverly Shores and 56 from Portage/Ogden Dunes. The median scheduled trip, the midpoint of all that day's westbound trip times, runs about 80, 70, 75 and 63 minutes. The weekend schedule is slower still, with fastest trips of 81, 71, 78 and 64 minutes.
The gap between the fastest and median trip is 12 minutes at Michigan City and Dune Park and 7 minutes at Beverly Shores and Portage. A buyer weighing Michigan City against Chesterton is really comparing an 80-minute weekday trip with a 70-minute one. A buyer planning a weekend house is comparing 81 minutes with 71.
Michigan City had a year with its station, and its median rose
Street-running trains in Michigan City ended on April 30, 2021, when the railroad began moving the tracks off 10th and 11th Streets onto two dedicated tracks. The new 11th Street Station and its parking garage opened June 18, 2025. WNDU reported the station as a $100 million project inside the $650 million Double Track build.
Right next to the station, Flaherty & Collins has built The Franklin at 11th Street. It's a $101 million, 12-story building with 220 market-rate apartments, ground-floor retail and a 549-space garage, according to The Times of Northwest Indiana. WNDU reported in May 2026 that starting rents were around $1,500 a month and that most units were reserved. The city's June 30, 2026 State of the City listed an August 1 end date for the project. In the Times coverage, EDC Michigan City director Clarence Hulse said there was "a lot of excitement downtown" and that businesses were looking forward to roughly 300 new residents. In separate Times coverage, Mayor Angie Nelson Deuitch said she expects projects like The Franklin to attract Chicago commuters and Illinois residents who keep working in the city.
Next on the city's list is 5th and Pine, a three-block downtown project for which the city selected Chicago-based DAC Developments to begin negotiations, Inside INdiana Business reported. The June 2026 State of the City still listed it as a future project with a preferred developer, about 500 market-rate units and a 40,000-square-foot grocery.
Now the sales. Michigan City's Northwest Indiana REALTORS Association MLS report puts the October 2026 median at $170,000, down 23.3% from October 2025. That single month comes from 35 sales, and the report itself warns that one month "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." Through October, the year-to-date median is $195,500, up 15.0% from the same stretch of 2025. The same report shows what that gain cost in speed. Year-to-date days on market rose from 32 to 41, and sellers received 93.1% of original list price, compared with 95.4% a year earlier. Prices rose, but buyers took longer to decide and negotiated more. That's typical of a market whose buyer pool is getting bigger faster than buyers are getting comfortable with it.
Munster and Dyer got their train in March, and their prices haven't moved with it
Monon Corridor passenger service began March 31, 2026. The eight-mile extension added four stations: Hammond Gateway, South Hammond, Munster Ridge and Munster/Dyer. The railroad's Monon Corridor FAQ estimates 45 minutes to an hour from Dyer to Millennium Station, depending on stops. The FAQ lists six inbound and six outbound weekday trains running straight to Chicago, with the remaining weekday service running as shuttles that require a transfer at Hammond Gateway, and off-peak and weekend riders transfer as well.
In Munster's MLS report, the year-to-date median through October 2026 is $360,000, down 1.0% from the same period of 2025. Year-to-date days on market held at 43, compared with 42. Dyer's year-to-date median is $345,900, up 6.4%, while its days on market lengthened from 27 to 34.
Sales figures alone can't tie Michigan City's gain to the train or predict where Munster goes next. Through October, seven months of new service, with only a handful of direct trains, hasn't yet changed what Munster homes sell for. A buyer who likes the Monon commute is still paying a 2025 price for it.
The Dune Park and Portage stations sit in between
Chesterton and Porter use Dune Park, which has the fastest typical Lakeshore trip of the towns here other than Portage. Chesterton's year-to-date median through October is $350,000, up 7.7%. Days on market fell from 45 to 38, and sellers received 96.4% of original list price. Portage has the shortest median trip of the four Lakeshore stations, at about 63 minutes. Its year-to-date median is $275,000, up 2.2%, and sellers received 97.3% of original list price, the highest share in this group.
Portage has had express service since 2024 and the steadiest numbers of the group. Prices are rising slowly, sellers are getting close to asking, and its October months' supply was 2.2. That fits a town whose short ride to the Loop is already reflected in its prices.
Here are both measures side by side:
| Station town | Typical weekday trip to Millennium | YTD median, Jan.–Oct. 2026 | Change vs. Jan.–Oct. 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michigan City | about 80 min | $195,500 | +15.0% |
| Chesterton, Dune Park station | about 70 min | $350,000 | +7.7% |
| Portage | about 63 min | $275,000 | +2.2% |
| Munster, Monon Corridor | 45–60 min, per railroad estimate | $360,000 | −1.0% |
| Dyer, Monon Corridor | 45–60 min, per railroad estimate | $345,900 | +6.4% |
Michigan City has the longest typical ride in the table, the lowest year-to-date median and the largest gain, while Portage and Munster, with shorter rides and higher or steadier prices, moved two percent or less in either direction.
Beverly Shores and the county numbers are too thin or too broad to read the same way
Beverly Shores has its own station, with a median weekday trip of about 75 minutes, but its sales volume can't support a trend. The Indiana REALTORS dashboard for ZIP code 46301 shows one closed sale in October 2026, at $1.8 million. The site's companion page of all 46301 metrics lists seven existing homes in inventory and median days on market of 118. With a market that small, a single lakefront sale can swing the median from one month to the next. Beverly Shores homes should be priced one property at a time.
County numbers have the opposite problem, because they pull in too many towns. The Indiana REALTORS LaPorte County report for October 2026 shows a $235,000 median, down 6% year over year, with inventory up 13%. Michigan City is in LaPorte County and was up 15% year to date over the same period. Porter County's October median was $343,000, up 11% year over year, according to the Porter County report. A Chicago buyer who stops at the county figure would get the wrong idea about Michigan City.
FAQ
Is the Michigan City express still 67 minutes? That was the advertised express time when the Double Track schedule launched in May 2024. The April 2026 weekday timetable's fastest Michigan City 11th Street train is 68 minutes, and the median trip is about 80.
Can I ride the Monon Corridor to Chicago on a weekend without changing trains? The railroad's FAQ says off-peak and weekend Monon service runs as shuttles with a transfer at Hammond Gateway. Its weekend schedule lists 24 shuttles.
Why did Michigan City's October median drop if the year is up? October's figure comes from 35 sales. The year-to-date median, built on 258 sales through October 2026, is the steadier number.
If you're weighing Michigan City against Chesterton or Munster and want to match the timetable to a specific home, Heidi Picard Properties can pull station-by-station comparables and walk you through how each town's sales are trending. If you already own along the line, start with a free home valuation built on your own town's year-to-date numbers, not the county's.